There is a sentence people are often told after being hurt:

"You need to forgive them for yourself."

It sounds compassionate.

Sometimes it is.

But I’m not convinced forgiveness should be treated as a psychological requirement.

I have worked with people who genuinely found freedom through forgiveness.

I have also worked with people who became more psychologically stable when they finally stopped trying to forgive someone they were not ready or did not want to forgive.

The problem begins when forgiveness stops being a possibility and becomes an expectation.

For some people, the pressure starts early.

A parent was neglectful, frightening or emotionally unavailable.

Later, the explanation arrives:

"They did the best they could."

"They had their own trauma."

"You need to understand what happened to them."

And often, those things are true.

Psychotherapy can help us understand how one generation transmits what it has never processed.

A parent may have been shaped by deprivation, violence, addiction, loss or their own attachment history.

Understanding that context can be enormously important.

But explanation and absolution are not the same psychological task.

Understanding why someone hurt you does not require you to decide that what happened was acceptable.

This distinction matters particularly in trauma work.

People sometimes arrive in therapy already highly skilled at explaining other people's behaviour.

They understand their father's childhood.

Their mother's anxiety.

Their partner's attachment difficulties.

Their sibling's addiction.

They can formulate everybody in the family.

What they struggle to do is say:

"And it still hurt me."

In these cases, pushing forgiveness too quickly can reproduce something familiar.

Once again, the person's attention moves away from their own experience and toward understanding the person who caused it.

The language has changed.

The relational pattern has not.

There is also a difference between forgiveness and relinquishing revenge.

Someone can decide:

I do not want to punish you.

I do not want my life organised around what you did.

I no longer need you to understand my pain.

I am not waiting for an apology.

I can accept that the past cannot be changed.

And still conclude:

"I do not forgive you."

Psychologically, that position may be considerably more resolved than repeatedly announcing forgiveness while remaining consumed by resentment.

We should be careful not to confuse the language of forgiveness with the process of resolution.

The same is true of reconciliation.

Forgiveness does not require restoring a relationship.

Understanding does not require access.

Compassion does not require proximity.

And healing does not require transforming the person who hurt us into a good person in our internal story.

Sometimes maturity involves holding two realities at once:

They were damaged too.

And they damaged me.

Their behaviour makes more sense when I understand their history.

And it was still their responsibility.

I can recognise their humanity.

And decide they cannot participate in my life.

Those are not contradictions.

They are often what complexity actually looks like.

Of course, refusing forgiveness can also become defensive.

Anger can organise an identity.

Resentment can preserve attachment just as effectively as love.

Remaining psychologically preoccupied with someone, whether through idealisation or hatred, can keep the relationship alive internally long after it has ended externally.

So the clinical question cannot simply become:

"You don't have to forgive."

That would be another slogan.

The more useful question is what the position is doing.

Is refusing forgiveness protecting an important boundary?

Or preserving a relationship through resentment?

Is forgiveness emerging from genuine integration?

Or from discomfort with anger?

Is someone moving forward?

Or performing what they believe a healed person should look like?

Perhaps healing is less about arriving at the correct emotional verdict on another person and more about reducing the amount of psychological territory they continue to occupy.

Eventually, the person who hurt you may become less central.

Not forgiven.

Not hated.

Not endlessly analysed.

Simply no longer organising your life.

The opposite of resentment may not always be forgiveness. Sometimes it is freedom from needing the relationship to end differently than it did.

That freedom may include forgiveness.

It may not.

Therapy should probably be spacious enough for both possibilities.

Because perhaps the important question is not:

"Have I forgiven them yet?"

But:

“How much of my present life still belongs to what happened in my past?”