If you ask most people what addiction treatment is for, the answer seems obvious.
To stop people using alcohol or drugs.
That is certainly part of it.
But after years of working in residential treatment, I have found myself asking a different question.
What happens when the substance disappears... but the person who needed it remains unchanged?
I don't mean unchanged in the sense of motivation.
Or intelligence.
Or willingness.
I mean something deeper.
The way they experience themselves.
The way they relate to other people.
The way they cope with shame, rejection, intimacy, anger, emptiness or fear.
Because for many people, addiction is not the only condition requiring treatment.
The substance is often the most visible problem.
It is not always the primary one.
Increasingly, clients arrive in treatment carrying years of emotional instability, chronic shame, unstable relationships, identity disturbance, perfectionism, emotional avoidance, dependency, or rigid interpersonal patterns.
Some meet the diagnostic criteria for a personality disorder.
Many do not.
But from a therapeutic perspective, those patterns still deserve our attention.
Because they profoundly influence recovery.
I sometimes wonder whether we underestimate the psychological role that substances play.
We often think of alcohol as reducing anxiety.
Cocaine as increasing confidence.
Opioids as numbing pain.
Those descriptions are true.
But they are incomplete.
Sometimes substances do something even more fundamental.
They temporarily change the relationship a person has with themselves.
For someone living with chronic shame, alcohol may briefly quiet the relentless inner critic.
For someone who experiences unbearable emptiness, opioids may offer a temporary sense of comfort that has never existed elsewhere.
For someone organised around inadequacy, stimulants may create, for a few hours, the version of themselves they have spent their entire life trying to become.
When viewed through this lens, addiction begins to make psychological sense.
Not because the substance solves the problem.
Because, for a time, it appears to solve the person.
This is why I believe abstinence, while essential, is rarely sufficient on its own.
Removing the substance without helping someone develop a different way of relating to themselves can leave them face-to-face with the very emotional world the addiction had been managing.
That is not a failure of motivation.
It is a clinical reality.
This is where personality functioning becomes an important part of the conversation.
Not because everyone entering treatment has a personality disorder.
They do not.
But because many people carry long-standing patterns of relating, regulating emotion and understanding themselves that continue long after detoxification has ended.
If those patterns remain untouched, recovery becomes considerably more difficult.
The question shifts from,
"How do we stop this person using?"
to something much more interesting.
"Who is this person when they no longer have the substance?"
Perhaps that is one of the next frontiers in addiction treatment.
Not replacing abstinence.
Not abandoning the extraordinary work already being done.
But recognising that sustainable recovery often requires us to treat both the addiction...
...and the person whose life became organised around needing it.
Because if we only treat the addiction, we may discharge someone sober...
...while leaving untouched the psychological patterns that made the addiction necessary in the first place.